Skip to content
Plain Payment

Deductible comparison calculator

Find out whether a higher deductible and a lower premium come out ahead.

What this calculator tells you

When you buy car or home insurance, you often get a choice between a lower deductible with a higher premium and a higher deductible with a lower premium. This calculator compares the two. It shows how much you save in premium each year, how many claim-free years it takes for the higher deductible to pay off, and which option has the lower expected cost at the chance of a claim you choose.

How to use it, step by step

  1. Enter the lower-deductible quote. The yearly premium and the deductible.
  2. Enter the higher-deductible quote. The same coverage, at a higher deductible.
  3. Estimate your chance of a claim. Think about your history, your vehicle or home, and where you live.
  4. Read the break-even and the expected cost. Then ask whether you could pay the higher deductible from savings.

A worked example

The lower-deductible policy costs $1,800 a year with a $500 deductible. The higher-deductible policy costs $1,550 with a $1,500 deductible. The premium saving is $250 a year, and the extra deductible is $1,000, so you need 4 claim-free years to break even. At a 10% yearly chance of a claim, the expected yearly cost is about $1,850 for the lower deductible and about $1,700 for the higher one, so the higher deductible is cheaper on average.

ChangePremium savingYears to break evenExpected cost, lower deductibleExpected cost, higher deductible
Base case: 10% chance of a claim$2504.0$1,850$1,700
5% chance$2504.0$1,825$1,625
20% chance$2504.0$1,900$1,850
30% chance$2504.0$1,950$2,000
Higher-deductible premium of $1,700 (saving only $100)$10010.0$1,850$1,850
Higher deductible of $2,500$2508.0$1,850$1,800
$1,400 premium, $2,500 deductible, 15% chance$4005.0$1,875$1,775

The higher deductible wins on average unless claims are frequent. In this example, the choice flips when the chance of a claim reaches about 25% a year. When the premium saving is small compared with the extra deductible, such as $100 against $1,000, the two options cost about the same, and the lower deductible gives you more protection for no extra cost.

How to read the results

The break-even number tells you how long you must go without a claim for the higher deductible to pay off. The expected costs average over many years, since you will not get an average year. In any single year, you either save the premium or pay the larger deductible. For that reason, the most important question is whether you could pay the higher deductible without trouble. Our guide to how deductibles work explains how deductibles differ across car, home, and health insurance.

What the calculator leaves out

  • Claims that raise premiums later.
  • Different deductibles for different perils, such as wind or hail.
  • How likely a claim really is for you.

Common mistakes

  • Choosing a deductible you could not pay. Savings should cover it.
  • Underestimating the chance of a claim. Include events such as hail, theft, and minor accidents.
  • Comparing quotes with different coverage. Keep everything else the same.
  • Forgetting to review it. As your savings grow, the right deductible may change.

See also the Homeowners deductible savings calculator, the Collision coverage worth it calculator, and the Self-insure vs. insure calculator.

Common questions

Does the tool include claim surcharges?

No. A claim can raise your premium for several years, which makes a higher deductible slightly more attractive if you would hesitate to file small claims.

How do I estimate the chance of a claim?

Look at your own history and your area. A rough guide is the number of claims you expect in ten years divided by ten.

Can I use it for health insurance?

Health deductibles work yearly and are followed by coinsurance, so use the Health plan comparison calculator instead.

How this calculator works

A higher deductible saves premium every year but costs more if you make a claim. The tool shows how many claim-free years it takes to come out ahead, and the expected cost of each option.

Break-even years = extra deductible ÷ yearly premium saving. Expected cost = premium + chance of a claim × deductible.

What this estimate leaves out

  • Claims that raise premiums later
  • Different deductibles for different perils
  • How likely a claim really is for you

Related calculators

Questions about these estimates

Are the results exact?

No. They are estimates based on the numbers you enter and the assumptions listed above. A lender, dealer, or insurer may use different fees, rounding, or rules.

Are the starting numbers current rates or prices?

No. They are examples. Replace each one with a figure from your own quote or statement.

Is my information saved?

No. The numbers you type stay in your browser and are not sent to us.

Estimates only. Not financial, legal, or insurance advice. See the disclaimer and the editorial policy.