Skip to content
Plain Payment

Self-insure vs. insure calculator

Compare the expected cost of buying insurance with paying a loss yourself.

How this calculator works

The tool compares the average yearly cost of each choice. It also shows the worst case, which matters most when a loss would strain your finances.

Expected cost with insurance = premium + chance × deductible. Without = chance × loss.

What this estimate leaves out

  • Losses of different sizes
  • Rules that require insurance
  • Your tolerance for risk

Related calculators

Questions about these estimates

Are the results exact?

No. They are estimates based on the numbers you enter and the assumptions listed above. A lender, dealer, or insurer may use different fees, rounding, or rules.

Are the starting numbers current rates or prices?

No. They are examples. Replace each one with a figure from your own quote or statement.

Is my information saved?

No. The numbers you type stay in your browser and are not sent to us.

Estimates only. Not financial, legal, or insurance advice. See the disclaimer and the editorial policy.